It’s not true that I left the country this morning because the Tories are back in power. But it is certainly interesting to see the processes of British politics through the eyes of a different country and culture. The Germans seem not to understand what all the fuss is about – they have a permanent ‘hung Parliament’ and seem to have done reasonably OK.
I am in Munich for the 2nd Ecumenical Kirchentag which began this afternoon and finishes on Sunday. The Protestants do this every other year, but this is the second time the Protestants and Roman Catholics have done it together (the last time seven years ago). Several hundred thousand people of all ages will be here during the next three days and tens of thousands joined together on the Theresienwiese for the opening service.
The service was interesting, but typically wordy. The theme of the Kirchentag is Damit ihr Hoffnung habt (‘So that you may have hope’) and the service attempted to get the word ‘Hoffnung’ into every sentence without ever really explaining what Christian hope might actually look like when ‘dressed’ in human flesh rather than existing simply as a theological idea.
The best bit was – surprisingly – the words of greeting brought at the end by the Bundespräsident, Professor Dr Horst Köhler. This is a bit like the Queen turning up and doing a talk to get the event going. Whereas Protestant black and Catholic Episcopal pink was to be seen everywhere, it was this lay politician who articulated what needed to be said and did so in language that was unambiguous, direct and honest. The scandal of child abuse by Roman Catholic priests has shattered Germany and, in Köhler’s words, hung a cloud over the churches and the Kirchentag itself. He spoke of the many people who had turned their back on the churches or been ashamed by their church, and called for support for victims of abuse.
The President then called the churches (a) to united witness by united worship and service; (b) repentance and transparent addressing of the sins of the church; but (c) not to lose sight of the good done by Christians in, through and from their churches. He strongly urged the churches to face the reality of their failures, but to remain confident both about the Gospel and the powerful good done and still to be done by the Christian churches in Germany. He was constantly applauded before concluding (along with Brother Roger of Taize) that Christians need both to struggle (its mission in and for society)and to be contemplative (rooted in reflective worship and prayer).
It was eloquent, passionate and articulate stuff. To hear a Head of State speak so powerfully, simply, clearly and honestly was very impressive. He was followed by the President of the State of Bavaria (Ministerpräsident), Horst Seehofer, who was equally direct, encouraging and funny. He welcomed us to his Land (state) and added that his Cabinet had agreed on Tuesday that there should be five days of good weather. He commented that we would soon find out what a politician’s word was worth. (Despite every weather forecast promising thunder storms and heavy rain, the evening was pleasant, cloudy and dry.)
Tomorrow begins with thousands of people flooding into the Messegelände for Bible studies, seminars, lectures, concerts, arts presentations, worship and every other kind of encounter. Rather than being preoccupied with abstract theology or disengaged spirituality, the programme is courageously aimed at addressing environmental, political, economic, social and ecclesiastical issues head on and making theology apply to the hard questions facing human beings in our societies now and for the future.
The Kirchentag probably couldn’t happen in Britain – but it is uniquely wonderful here.
May 12, 2010 at 11:21 pm
Hi Bishop Nick,
I am guessing (1 in a Thousand chance or less) that you might see Bishop Alan of Buckingham, I know he was also in Munich today as he responded to my Email inviting him to my talk.
Sounds Good, If it is as Good as Greenbelt Carnival was then I would love to go, assuming it was not Ordained Personnel there. Do the Anglican Bishops Not wear Purple at these events. I thought Bishops weather Anglican or Catholic, they were purple.
A politician being honest, well that seems like a dream, but I think it will happen especially now that we have a Collation Government. May be our politicians and newspapers should go to Germany, instead of that they went to New Zealand.
Hope the rest of your trip is just as great,
Many Thanks
Anthony.
May 13, 2010 at 4:47 am
I was very impressed by the president’s words. It’s as though people in the middle of the Churchy Bubble are struggling to articulate something much more clear to everyone outside. This in itself is a strong argument for events that bring the two together on a mass scale like this. I may try and get along to the special podium event tomorrow at 11 in C1, although I suspect I won’t be at the Norbert Leygraf do this evening, as duty calls to be at Meissen service!
May 13, 2010 at 6:08 am
We get Tweedeledum & Tweedledee in Downing Street Garden…and you get incisive theology from a politician. There’s no justice!
May 13, 2010 at 3:34 pm
Isn’t it ironical that so many of the lessons we taught the new Federal Republic in 1945-48 should now be re-exported back to the UK. Could we start with two things:- The proportional representation system (especially the 5% hurdle to exclude the wild eyed fanatics) and the Kirchentag.
The new management may make a slow start on the first, but what would it take for the churches in the UK to undertake a similar festival to the Muenchen Kirchentag? Yes, we know the expense, but this hasn’t prevented thousands from camping im muddy fields or holiday camps attending their factionally favoured Spring and Summer gatherings. The real benefit would be putting say 90,000 folk into Wembley, Twickenham or the O2 and then summoning our political leaders to share their personal values like the Bundespräsident. The message of Christian unity would also help deny the secular propagandists their weapon of pointing out our disunity and inter-denominational warfare, something our German friends learned that they couldn’t afford in the 1930′s.
May 14, 2010 at 2:08 pm
…”the programme is courageously aimed at addressing environmental, political, economic, social and ecclesiastical issues head on and making theology apply to the hard questions facing human beings in our societies now and for the future.
The Kirchentag probably couldn’t happen in Britain – but it is uniquely wonderful here.”
Aha, +Nick, yes, you should go to the Greenbelt Festival this year, as that statement pretty much captures what GB is about
PB
May 14, 2010 at 9:06 pm
Peter, I usually do go to Greenbelt, but can’t go this year. However, Greenbelt is a different beast from the Kirchentag. For a start, there are estimated to be 400,000 people at this one…
May 15, 2010 at 12:06 am
I clearly stand corrected… a serious number of extra loaves and fishes needed! Will catch up at GB 2011 maybe?